Monday, January 9, 2017

On Tilikum & Statistics

While so many of us were busy thanking our respective deities that the fiasco that was 2016 has passed, the new year is already off to a heartbreaking start – at least for the animal care community, and especially for SeaWorld Orlando’s zoological team.  On January 6, 2017, the infamous killer whale Tilikum passed away from a chronic lung infection at an estimated 36 years old.

Tilikum’s death represents a huge loss—literally, he was over 20 feet long and weighed in at more than 12,000 pounds. On an even larger scale, though, this whale inspired millions of people to care for all marine mammals by connecting them to the beauty, intelligence, and pure majesty of nature.  His impact on the trainers who worked with him, the guests who connected with him, and the wild whales who now benefit from a more passionate society will continue long beyond his last breath. 

Photo of Tilikum by SeaWorld.

While it is certainly worth just taking the time to recognize Tilikum’s enormous lifetime impact on humans and animals alike, the main reason I wanted to write this post was to address a long-standing misunderstanding that has resurfaced with this tragedy: do killer whales (and all cetaceans) in zoos and aquariums live shorter lives than their wild counterparts?  A few subtle factors make answering this question much more complicated than it seems.

First of all, lifespan statistics are generally difficult to accurately assess because it takes a lot of time, and a little luck, to collect truly representative life history data on any whale population.  Due to cetaceans’ long life cycle, decades of research may be required to develop a thorough data set on any given pod.  Additionally, if a population resides in formidable climates (such as Antarctic subtypes), migrates long or unpredictable distances (e.g. transient whales), or lives far from coastal regions (for example, offshore ecotypes), it is nearly impossible acquire consistent, representative population data.  As a result, not all life history statistics are well-understood – including those of the Icelandic population that Tilikum was born into.  However, although information from one ecotype does not necessarily represent all others, it certainly gives us a better idea of the species’ general survivorship patterns than no data at all. 

Arguably the best-studied killer whale pods are the two "resident" populations off the coast of Canada.  While their lifespan parameters may differ somewhat from those of Icelandic whales, the residents are considered some of the longest-lived due to one female nicknamed "Granny" who was estimated to have survived somewhere between 90 and 105 years.  Therefore, data collected from these animals represents a liberal estimate for other populations, making it an ideal set for comparison. (Sad side note: a few days ago, scientists announced that they haven’t seen Granny recently and are therefore assuming her deceased.  It's been a rough week for Orcinus orca.)

Photo of J2 "Granny" in 2010 by the Center for Whale Research.

From 1973 through 2004, Olesiuk and colleagues collected data on the aforementioned resident populations in the northeast Pacific.  Their research estimated the female average lifespan to be between 30 and 50 years, depending on the group and time period, and approximated males between 19 and 31 years (see Table 14 in Olesiuk report).  Tilikum passed at 36 years of age, five years older than the upper average male estimate deduced by Olesiuk et al. (2005).

It is important to note that maximum longevity is different from average longevity.  The same study also estimated that males in these populations have a maximum longevity of somewhere between 40 and 70 years, but of course this doesn’t imply that every individual is expected to live that long.  It’s kind of like saying that although the oldest human ever recorded was a 122-year-old female in France, the average male lifespan in the United States is estimated around 76 years, and we obviously wouldn’t consider an American man who passed at 85 years old to have “died young” since he didn’t surpass the world record.  Similarly, no unbiased observer would consider Tilikum to have passed prematurely since he didn’t live up to the 100-year record estimated for a female, but exceeded the 19-31 approximation for average male lifespan.

Okay, so maybe you'll agree that Tilikum didn't die young in this one case, but what about all of the other whales in human care?  If you take the average age of all whales in zoos and aquariums and compare it to the wild, you will find that those numbers look different.  However, consider that Granny may have survived past 100 years, but killer whales have only been in human care for about 50 (and our ability to care for them has improved exponentially during that time).  Therefore, it’s impossible for the zoological population to mirror the dynamics of a wild one, making the comparison of average member age inherently inappropriate.

Additionally, even well-studied populations aren’t visible during certain times of the year, and as a result calves are usually first spotted around six months of age.  The problem is that if a calf dies before they’ve been recorded, they will never make it into the calculation for average lifespan – and this is significant since upwards of 40% of calves are estimated to die within their first six months (nature is brutal, people.).  However, of course we have all data for populations in zoos and aquariums, so any young calves that die in human care are usually included when calculating average age of death.  The result?  Many people wind up comparing statistics between uncontrolled groups (the zoological one including deaths of calves aged less than six months, the wild one excluding them).  And that, my friends, is what we call bad science.


Another side note: because they receive world-class health care and protection from natural threats, calves in human care have a significantly higher chance of surviving to two years of age than those in the southern resident population (.966 versus .795, p < .04; excluded zoological calves that survived less than 40 days to control for sighting bias) (Robeck et al. 2015).  Pictured here is Kasatka with her fourth calf Makani at SeaWorld San Diego.

All of this is to show that a lot of the statistics you’ve probably seen in the popular media are—and excuse my language here—baloney. So, how can we accurately compare these two necessarily distinct populations to see if there actually is a significant difference?  One way is to look at year-to-year survival rate, or what percentage of each population survives on average to the next year. Luckily for us, a group of researchers have already crunched those numbers: Robeck and colleagues (2015) calculated the southern and northern resident populations' annual survival rates (0.966 and 0.977, respectively) and found that these numbers were not significantly different from that of SeaWorld's whales from 2000 to 2015 (0.976).


These survival statistics are indicative of the quality of care that animals receive in accredited zoos and aquariums today, and the stimulation and health care provided for Tilikum during his nearly 25 years at SeaWorld Orlando was no different.  While he has been portrayed in the media in a very negative light, his trainers say that he had a fun-loving personality and enjoyed relationship-building sessions.  If you want to know more about this, I recommend checking out one of SeaWorld’s publications or this video from one of his former trainers.

Tilikum with trainers during an enrichment session.  Photo by SeaWorld.

Animal rights organizations are aggressively spreading false statistics and emotionally-compelling (but not accurate) claims that threaten the well-being of all cetaceans in human care today by pushing for their release, which would likely have lethal consequences (just as it did for Keiko).  This movement is based on emotion, not logic, and because of this ignorance, its propaganda is actively hurting the animals that it's claiming to help.  Although you may choose not to go to a zoo or you may disagree with the idea of animals in human care, I hope everyone will critically consider statements made in the media and by extremist groups.


One of the biggest impacts Tilikum had was inspiring millions of people to care about killer whales, and we desperately need that passion to continue beyond his passing.  The same southern resident population that I've referenced several times throughout this post is rapidly declining because of severe food shortage, boat traffic, and pollutant bioaccumulation.  Other populations of whales around the world are also facing myriad threats from global warming and human activity.  Learning about killer whale conservation initiatives, consuming sustainable seafood, and disposing of waste appropriately are just a few doable things that can make a huge difference for the lives of wild whales and the entire natural world, and in my opinion it is one of the best ways to honor Tilikum's memory.

My condolences are with the SeaWorld Orlando training team and all those whose lives were touched by this magnificent whale.



Sunday, June 5, 2016

On Harambe & the Internet

This week’s internet debate has centered around the shooting of Harambe, a 400-pound silverback western lowland gorilla at the Cincinnati Zoo, after a four-year-old boy fell into the moat surrounding his exhibit.  As per usual when it comes to animal rights issues, facts seem to be missing from most of these conversations; although I am certainly not an expert on gorilla behavior, I wanted to take an opportunity to synthesize some of the informed opinions that experienced professionals have expressed this week, in addition to some of the information I’ve gathered across seven years of working in zoological environments as it relates to this situation.

No experience is best experience!

Before I go any further with this, I need to acknowledge again that I have never worked with gorillas, or directly with any primate species (well, aside from humans, although to be honest I actually don't consider myself that good at working with those).  However, many people with way less (read: zero) zoological experience have also felt it necessary to offer their opinion on this situation; as much as I love a good misinformed keyboard war, I hope to offer some perspective as someone who has dedicated more than 2,000 unpaid hours to working behind-the-scenes at three AZA-accredited facilities. 

The first thing that needs to be clarified is that this is not a scene from The Jungle Book.  Gorillas—especially full-grown males—are inherently dangerous.  Even when not aggravated, their strength (at least six times that of an adult human) means that they can cause serious injury with even an absent-minded swipe.  Although gorillas have been observed as one of the gentler species of great apes, they are still considered Class I: in the same category as lions and tigers and bears, oh my!  In my experience working around other Class I mammals, the functioning assumption among their keepers is that if you wind up unprotected in the same space as one of those animals, you will die.  It doesn’t matter if you raised the tiger from birth, or if you’ve been working with the bear for ten years, or if you’re a helpless child that fell into the gorilla’s space: from a Dangerous Animal Response Team (DART) perspective, the unfortunate decision came down to the human life or the animal’s.

Uhh... #fitnessgoals?

Another hot topic that everyone seems to have thoughts on is whether there were other options aside from shooting the animal.  The keepers did initially try to recall all three gorillas (Harambe and his two lady friends), but despite the promise of treats inside, it’s not surprising that he chose to stay out considering the anxious energy of the crowd and the rarity of his new EED (environmental enrichment device, AKA the kid).  Since Harambe was not leaving the child voluntarily, many people have suggested that the zoo “should” have used a tranquilizer instead of a shot.  I’m also not an expert on tranquilizers, but there are some reasonable questions to be raised about the logistics of this recommendation.

Because of the blood-brain barrier and the time it takes drugs to be absorbed into cells, depending on the type and amount of sedative used, a tranquilizer dart injected into a muscle could have taken anywhere from five to thirty minutes to start taking effect, and some tranquilizers even have an initial excitatory phase.  Not to mention, an animal that has just been shot would probably have a reaction to that aversive stimulus.  Because the kid could have been killed in one blow as mentioned earlier, the added time and risk of using a tranquilizer could not be afforded.

Additionally, the amount of tranquilizing agent that would be needed in this situation is a big question mark.  On the one hand, since the gorilla was already wound up and the response team would need him to be knocked out as quickly as possible, they would likely have chosen to use more sedative than normal.  However, this opens up a risky situation: the more drugs used, the less likely the animal is to wake back up.  All things considered, the use of a tranquilizer would have created an even more dangerous situation for the child and would not have even guaranteed to keep Harambe alive.

Science and facts and stuff: recommended for use 
before pulling out the tranquilizing gun.
The next subject to come up is regarding how the kid got into the moat in the first place, and everyone’s first reaction seems to be pointing fingers at the parents.  Obviously, I’m even less of an expert on parenting than I am on gorillas (I generally try to stay as far away from young humans as possible), but I can attest that at each zoological facility I’ve been at, kids get lost ALL the time.  Granted, they usually don’t try to climb into the animal exhibits while unsupervised, but the fact is that no parent is perfect.  While it’s fun to play the blame game while hiding behind a keyboard, consider that this mother’s one moment of inattentiveness led to the loss of a truly priceless animal and serious injuries to her offspring—far graver consequences than most parents have ever had to confront.  Instead of pointing fingers, I encourage all of you that are responsible for children (be it through parenting, babysitting, or supervising your drunk friends) to take this incident as a sobering reminder of the huge weight that your job carries.

Questions have also been raised about the exhibit barrier and whether it is sufficient to keep both humans and animals safe.  In the past few decades, exhibits have been evolving toward a more naturalistic aesthetic and moving away from the steel bars and concrete floors characteristic of early zoos.  Exhibit designers always have animal security first in mind, and most exhibits have multiple barriers to the animal getting out of any enclosure.  Railings and various other obstacles generally keep humans safe from falling into exhibits, assuming the visitors are abiding by the posted and implied safety guidelines (e.g., don’t crawl between the fence wires, through the bushes, and into the moat).  However, with this situation and several related incidents, such as the guy who jumped into a lion yard last month, keeping humans out is surprisingly becoming just as critical as keeping animals in.  In addition to Cincinnati’s recent modification to the fence surrounding the gorilla exhibit, zoos all over the nation will likely be re-evaluating their barriers from the human side to avoid further catastrophes.  (Granted, these catastrophes could also be avoided with common sense, but as we keep seeing you can't count on that.)

The zookeeper's thought process when it comes to guest safety, let's be honest.

At this point, I hope you’re starting to understand how this whole fiasco happened and why the related decisions were made.  Maybe you (like 99% of the internet) are still stuck in the second stage of grief, but maybe you’re ready to accept what happened as an accident that was handled appropriately to save the child, and take a step back to evaluate what each one of us can do to improve the welfare of the other ~125,000 western lowland gorillas that we share the world with.  Beyond this one death in the US, wild populations are disappearing from their native forest habitats at an astonishing rate: due to a combination of Ebola outbreak, bushmeat hunting, and habitat loss, the entire population is predicted to decrease by about 80% over the next three generations.  If you really want to help gorillas, please consider learning about or even donating to relevant conservation projects, such as the Wildlife Wood Project or the Wildlife Conservation Society's work.  Additionally, zoos all over the nation are participating in the gorilla Species Survival Plan, a collaborative breeding effort to preserve the species, and reproductive biologists collected viable sperm from Harambe so his genes can continue contributing to this effort and live on in the next generation.

Finally, I just want to emphasize one more element of this situation: while the nation might be sad and enraged about his death, there is no one that loved Harambe more than the keepers that worked with him every day and literally dedicate their lives to his species.  Not you, not me, not the fun people at PETA, no one loved that individual more.  My condolences go out to those keepers, and I implore all the rest of you to take the energy raised by this incident off the internet comment boards and apply it toward actually helping animals, both those in zoos and out in the wild.


Saturday, October 10, 2015

On Politics & Animal Welfare

This week, I remembered why I’m not a politics major.

On Thursday, the California Coastal Commission held a hearing about whether or not to approve SeaWorld’s plans to build a new killer whale exhibit that would create an immersive viewing experience for guests and, more importantly, effectively double the size of their orca pools.  After nine-plus hours of extremely impassioned speeches, testimonies, and presentations from animal experts and sign-bearing citizens alike, the Commission unanimously voted to approve SeaWorld San Diego’s expansion—on the condition that they stop breeding and transferring their whales.  Now it’s up to SeaWorld to decide which constraint to accept.

An aerial view of the proposed expansion to the existing
killer whale facility at SeaWorld San Diego.

From my perspective, watching this debate from my dorm room and procrastinating on my actual biology homework, this decision felt like a bunch of politicians trying to reach a compromise to simultaneously make two incompatible groups happy: if SeaWorld can build their new attraction, then animal rights activists can relax knowing that the whales are “banned” from ever breeding again, a decision that would extinguish California's population of killer whales in human care over the next fifty to 100 years.  But I didn't see much evidence that anyone was really thinking about what would make the most important party in this discussion happy: the whales themselves.

Of course, happiness is not a particularly measurable trait, especially in animals.  However, we can consider how this political outcome will interact with their biological and societal needs.

This ruling could produce a few different outcomes.  SeaWorld might pass up the condition and continue to hold and breed their whales in the existing pool system.  Alternatively, they could accept the new condition, build a really cool pool, and try to prevent the whales from breeding.  It’s also possible that the company will try to overturn the breeding ban, since the California Coastal Commission is only supposed to regulate land use, not animal welfare, but I don’t know enough about the intricacies of politics to make meaningful comment on this possibility.  Instead, let’s consider the consequences for the whales if either of the former two paths are taken.


Kasatka (bottom) with two of her four calves, Kalia and Makani,
and Kalia's calf Amaya.  Photo courtesy SeaWorld San Diego.
First, let’s say SeaWorld decides to continue breeding their whales and sacrifice the plans for a new pool, which would mean literally nothing changes.  This would be a sadly-wasted opportunity to significantly improve the space currently available to these animals.  Surprisingly, many animal rights activists are opposed to the expansion at all, saying it wouldn't make a difference in the whales' lives.  One of the most common arguments at the hearing revolved around the fact that no pool will ever be comparable to a whale’s natural range.  True, but consider this: of the eleven whales at the San Diego park, eight were born in a zoological facility.   Five of those eight were born at SeaWorld San Diego.  Whether you feel it should or shouldn't be this way, the fact is that that pool system is the only environment that most of those whales know.  Doubling the size of the space available to them might not come anywhere close to the space available in the ocean, but it would be a significant improvement relative to their particular situation.  If SeaWorld chose not to accept the terms of the BWP approval, the opportunity to vastly expand the only home that they know would be squandered.

A coastal seapen concept (perhaps as a prequel to release) has also been suggested to give the animals a larger and more naturalistic environment.  While this idea holds an almost romantic appeal to people, it comes with significant risks to the welfare of both the captive and wild populations.  I won’t get too far into this debate here, but the risks of release include genetic pollution, the captive whales’ ability to transition from a sterile environment to the ocean, disease transfer between captive and wild populations, marine pollution and environmental hazards, depleting food sources, and lack of cultural hunting knowledge.  The short version is, there’s no CTRL+Z for this whole situation.

The other option is that SeaWorld goes forward with the Blue World Project and agrees not to breed their whales.  Let’s talk about the logistics of this agreement, starting with a fact: animals have sex.

The trainers can do some pretty amazing behavior modification, but sitting the whales down and saying “hey, we’re going to build you a sweet new pool, but you have to keep your genetics to yourself, okay?” is not exactly in their wheelhouse.  Also, since cetaceans have to be conscious to breathe, anesthetizing the animals to spay or neuter them is not an option.  There are only two known ways to prevent the whales from breeding: female oral contraceptives and physical separation.  Unfortunately, each comes with welfare consequences.

Let’s say that all of the females are put on altrenogest, a progestin that essentially suppresses estrus.  This compound was initially developed primarily for horses, but it has also been used short-term for cetaceans and seems to be safe and relatively effective.  However, if the orcas are hereafter banned from breeding, the females would need to be on this compound (or some other form of new, potentially untested birth control) for their entire lives.  Think about when you’re sick: it’s recommended to take the minimum effective amount of a drug for the shortest time possible, because the risks of taking any kind of synthetic compound long-term will eventually build up.  An animal being on contraceptives for their entire life just isn’t healthy.

The other option, then, is the scenario known as the middle school dance paradigm: males on one side, females on the other.  Aside from negating the social stability intentions of the approval conditions’ ban on transferring animals, separation will take away opportunities for social enrichment and weaken the familial bonds that this highly social species depends on.  Even this method is not always completely effective, as animals can interact (and potentially, although the likelihood is low, procreate) through gates.

In any case, we all know that no form of birth control is 100% effective for any species (humans included), and accidental pregnancies have happened in the past.  So, what would happen if one of the whales did get pregnant, even if SeaWorld was taking appropriate measures to prevent it?  (Imagine if we had to extend the abortion debate to whales... Just the thought is exhausting.)  My point is, it’s really easy for policy-makers to tell a facility that they’re banned from breeding their animals, but it’s much harder for the caretakers—the people on the ground floor who literally dedicate their lives to the well-being of those animals—to put it into practice in a healthy, balanced, and effective way.

So, since politicians are obviously so dead-set on attempting to regulate a complex issue, let's think about some policy compromises that would actually benefit the whales.  For example, the government could limit the number of whales SeaWorld can hold or put a cap on the number of births they could [hypothetically] have in a set amount of time, which would prevent overcrowding and maximize the space available to the animals while potentially mandating occasional separations and short-term contraceptive use.  They could prevent the company from importing wild-caught cetaceans from countries with less stringent policies on marine mammal management, although SeaWorld has already pledged to this agreement on their own.  But “banning” breeding altogether—a decision that, by the way, really should be made by the whales’ caretakers and veterinarians, not politicians—is simply not a healthy policy for the animals in question.

At its core, the Blue World Project decision just doesn’t leave reasonable room for a net improvement in the whales’ welfare.  Each option comes with a trade-off for the animals, but it doesn’t have to—it is only because of our human emotional and societal constructs that we mandated a compromise between two opposing groups, a compromise that just doesn’t help anyone except for soothing the egos of those in die-hard support of the extremist “anti-captivity” movement. 

The thing is, the entire ordeal regarding Blue World Project, and animal affairs in general, shouldn’t have been about one group being “proved” right or wrong by a bunch of politicians.  This should be analyzed as the effects that it will have on the whales, because at the end of the day, that’s who we’re supposed to be fighting for, right?  The animals—not our egos.

If absolutely nothing else, we should be able to find unity 
in the fact that we all LOVE animals, right? 
(Is it even possible not to love this face?!)

You can disagree with SeaWorld’s method of making money, you can disagree with the entire practice of keeping animals in human care, you can personally choose not to visit zoos and aquariums.  That’s all okay.  What’s not okay is ignoring facts and using an emotionally-constructed opinion to block off any attempts to improve animal welfare on the basis of a human-oriented compromise.